Nicholas Coles, a psychology professor at the University of Florida, led research challenging the idea that forced smiling improves mood. Coles and colleagues Annabel Dang and Joao Francisco Goes Braga Takayanagi published their findings in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology on October 1.

The team designed an online experiment with 1,174 participants to mimic customer service demands. Participants viewed images meant to trigger different emotions, from appealing ones like kittens to disturbing scenes. Some were instructed to smile deliberately, others to let expressions form naturally. Half completed the task once; half repeated it 10 times. Researchers told half the participants they could lose $2 from their $6 payment if they failed to smile properly, though no one actually lost money.

Results showed a single smile produced a modest mood boost when viewing unpleasant images, even with financial pressure. But repeated smiling eliminated this benefit. When viewing pleasant images, repeatedly forced smiling actually lowered happiness ratings compared to natural expressions. Forced smiling was also linked to increased irritation and anger in pleasant image conditions.

Coles said the findings explain why workplace smile requirements can backfire. Target faced criticism for a policy requiring employees to smile when customers approached. Coles argues such mandates prevent natural emotional expression and limit freedom for both employees and customers.

Coles raised a broader question: whether focusing less on manufacturing happiness and more on contentment might serve people better. "We have placed such an immense amount of emphasis on trying to make ourselves feel happier than we currently are," he said, "much less emphasis on just being content with what we have."