A study of six teachers at two South African secondary schools found that school principals can support professional development but often fail to do so consistently, particularly at under-resourced schools.
Researchers from Cape Peninsula University of Technology conducted semi-structured interviews with teachers who had over three years of experience at one quintile 1 school, which serves the country's poorest communities, and one quintile 5 school, which serves the wealthiest. The study examined how principals lead teacher development.
Three themes emerged. Teachers at both schools viewed continuous professional development as essential for adapting to changing learners and staying current with policy and teaching methods. One teacher stated: "The learners of five years ago are not the same learners that we are teaching now."
On content knowledge support, researchers found no direct principal influence on teachers' subject matter expertise. At the quintile 5 school, the principal indirectly supported development by arranging sessions led by subject advisors and departmental heads. Teachers at the quintile 1 school reported receiving no such support from their principal and viewed departmental workshops as "tick-box exercises."
For classroom management skills, a major challenge in South African public schools, support diverged by school type. Teachers at the quintile 1 school received no principal support for handling disruptive behavior. At the quintile 5 school, the principal enforced a code of conduct with consequences, helping teachers manage disruption.
The researchers call on principals to identify professional learning needs, involve teachers in development decisions, create training opportunities, and collaborate with departmental heads so professional development becomes substantive rather than compliance-focused.