A survey of 4,295 young people in England found that among those who did not progress to higher education, only half of those in work secured permanent contracts by ages 19 to 20. This represents a sharp decline from 81% in a comparable study conducted six years earlier.

The research, led by Sharon Gewirtz, a professor of education at King's College London, tracked participants born in 2004 or 2005 from ages 15 to 16 through 19 to 20 across three waves from May 2021 to January 2025. Just 16% of young people without higher education secured apprenticeships, and only 23% had secured stable work by ages 19 to 20.

Temporary and casual work were linked with worse pay, poorer workplace relationships and poorer job design compared to apprenticeships or stable work. Young people who experienced mental health difficulties, unfair treatment or bullying at ages 15 to 16 were more likely to experience poorer relationships and have less say at work two years later.

The proportion classified as not in education, employment or training (NEET) more than doubled from 4% at ages 17 to 18 to 10% at ages 19 to 20. More than 40% of those who were NEET at ages 17 to 18 remained so two years later. Around seven in 10 NEET respondents were either actively seeking work or education or engaged in volunteer or unpaid caregiving work.

Substantial inequalities emerged in apprenticeship access. Young people from Asian and Black backgrounds applied to apprenticeships at similar rates to white peers but were significantly less likely to secure a place, by approximately 15 and 12 percentage points respectively. Black young people not in education were approximately 24 percentage points less likely to be in stable employment than white peers at ages 19 to 20.

Gewirtz stated the system is "riven by inequalities and that is simply not delivering enough decent opportunities." She emphasized the need to focus on "increasing and equalizing access to good work" by tackling low pay, unfair recruitment practices and strengthening protections against oppressive work cultures.