Researchers analyzing 273 results reports from agricultural climate research projects found that partnerships and institutional collaboration rarely appear explicitly connected to how innovations scale, according to a study published in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems.
Deissy Martínez-Barón from the International Center for Tropical Agriculture and the University of Copenhagen, Anne Gravsholt Busck from the University of Copenhagen, and Steven Dean Prager from the Gates Foundation examined reports covering 261 projects across 12 CGIAR research programs between 2018 and 2021. They identified a gap between documented scaling outcomes and how social and institutional conditions contribute to achieving them.
The researchers used latent Dirichlet allocation, a computational method, to identify 17 topics grouped into four areas: agricultural systems, climate change adaptation, climate change mitigation and enabling environments. They found that reports document collaborative relationships and scaling outcomes but rarely make explicit how relationships of trust and partnerships influence the process.
The study describes three scaling pathways: scaling out, when innovations reach more people and places; scaling up, when they influence policies and institutions; and scaling deep, when relationships, practices and social norms are transformed. The reports show examples of scaling out and scaling up, but scaling deep remains underdeveloped in the documents.
The researchers cited examples of scaling success involving social capital. One documented the spread of drought-tolerant bean varieties to more than 10,000 farmers across three countries through partnerships among national agricultural research organizations, seed companies and farmer associations. Another example showed how collaboration between researchers and governments contributed to including agroclimatic information in countries' climate commitments under the Paris Agreement.
The authors recommend that governments, development organizations and research programs explicitly integrate social capital into planning and monitoring scaling strategies, including identifying actors and relationships and incorporating indicators of trust, collaboration and network diversity. They note that networks can generate inequalities or exclude certain actors, requiring attention to these dynamics for responsible scaling.