A reanalysis of galaxy UHZ1 challenges a 2021 claim that it hosts an exceptionally massive black hole in the early universe. The new study, led by Fan Zou of the University of Michigan and published in The Astrophysical Journal on October 14, finds no compelling evidence for such a black hole.
The original observation came from the James Webb Space Telescope, which spotted UHZ1 when the universe was approximately 480 million years old. Astronomers using the Chandra X-ray telescope detected a small excess of high-energy X-rays and interpreted it as a black hole actively feeding on gas, with mass estimates between 10 million and 100 million solar masses. This would have supported the theory of a "direct collapse black hole" that forms directly from collapsing gas rather than growing slowly from stellar remnants.
Zou's team reprocessed all archived Chandra data and added 0.95 million seconds of new X-ray observations. They also analyzed new mid-infrared data from JWST. The reanalysis revealed a weaker X-ray detection than originally reported. Simulations of plausible X-ray and JWST image alignments showed that only 0.1 percent produced a signal as strong as the original claim. When new observing time was added, the X-ray data showed almost no additional signal, which should not occur for a real source.
Mid-infrared observations searching for the thermal emission expected from dust heated by a buried black hole found no such glow. The team used this non-detection to set an upper limit on brightness. Any hidden black hole powerful enough to match the original claim would have produced infrared emission 10 to 1,000 times brighter than what MIRI could detect.
The team concludes that UHZ1 is more likely a metal-poor, star-forming galaxy with stellar mass around 100 million solar masses, requiring no black hole to explain the observed emission lines.