Queensland trialled youth justice boot camps between 2013 and 2015, with young people participating in structured daily activities, physical challenges, education and behavioural development. An independent evaluation by KPMG found significant problems with program design, implementation and costs. Of 35 young people who completed the program, 24 went on to re-offend, with re-offending highest among those who did not receive support to reintegrate into their communities. Queensland subsequently discontinued the boot camps.
Victoria's Coalition proposes converting the former Dhurringile Prison near Shepparton into a boot camp for offenders aged 14 to 17, with participants following strict daily routines involving farm work, cleaning, maintenance, cooking and education. Labor Premier Ben Carroll has announced a $204 million mandatory rehabilitation scheme instead, combining residential detention for up to 12 months with education, drug and alcohol treatment, mental health support and practical life skills programs.
Research shows that traditional boot camps emphasizing discipline, physical training and strict behavioural control have not consistently translated into reduced offending after release, even when they improved participants' attitudes, physical fitness or behaviour. Therapeutic programs focusing on underlying factors that contribute to offending show more promise. These can include cognitive behavioural therapy, family-based interventions, and substance use, mental health and education support, though their effectiveness depends on program design, appropriate targeting and implementation.
Removing young people from their families, schools and communities can disrupt the relationships and protective factors that support their rehabilitation. Joel Robert McGregor, Senior Lecturer in Criminology at Swinburne University of Technology, notes that community-based interventions can address offending behaviour while allowing young people to maintain these important connections.