A study at a medieval monastery in Old Dongola, Sudan has revealed something museums and heritage sites worldwide should take seriously: the way people look at art is fundamentally shaped by their cultural background. Researchers including Marwa Satti, Mohammed Hassan Siedahmed, and Tobiasz Trawinski invited 48 Sudanese participants and 19 Western participants to observe medieval paintings while wearing eye-tracking glasses. The findings were striking. While both groups ultimately spent similar amounts of time viewing the same elements—faces, bodies, attributes, and context—they took entirely different visual routes to get there.
The data showed clear differences in how attention was directed. Western participants focused first on human figures, particularly faces and bodies, before turning to objects, clothing, or symbols. Sudanese participants, by contrast, initially focused on attributes like objects before shifting to faces and broader context. These differences likely reflect how cultural knowledge shapes what we find meaningful. When Sudanese participants saw a key in a painting, they recognized it from everyday life. Western participants familiar with Christian iconography were more likely to identify biblical figures by their faces. Neither approach is wrong—they're simply different pathways shaped by different backgrounds.
This research matters because it exposes a major problem in how heritage is currently presented. For decades, archaeology in Africa was dominated by Western perspectives. While this is changing, with local communities becoming more involved in the research and interpretation of their cultural heritage, most presentations still assume a single way of looking at the past. The study, conducted at Kom H monastery in Old Dongola, demonstrates why that approach is insufficient. When heritage presentations skip over the attributes that immediately engage local audiences in favor of narrative strategies designed around Western viewing patterns, they're failing part of their audience.
The implications are practical and urgent. Heritage managers should use these insights to develop culturally adapted presentations. If particular attributes attract the gaze of Sudanese visitors—as this study shows they do—then heritage displays could introduce paintings through these elements first. A museum exhibition might begin with the objects depicted in a scene before moving to figures and broader context, creating a more resonant experience for local audiences. The same flexibility should apply to Western audiences, whose tendency to focus on human figures could be acknowledged and worked with rather than against.
Understanding how people look at heritage is ultimately about respect and inclusion. It's about moving from presenting the past in a single, predetermined way toward creating narratives that recognize different ways of encountering and making sense of history. The eye-tracking study at Old Dongola provides the evidence. Now heritage institutions must act on it.