A new study from Skoltech and MISIS University has cracked open a fundamental puzzle in materials science: why graphite doesn't transform directly into the most stable form of diamond under pressure. Instead, it first creates lonsdaleite, a hexagonal diamond structure, before potentially converting to the familiar cubic form. This finding, published in the journal Carbon, challenges our assumptions about how nature always takes the most efficient path to stability.
The paradox seems straightforward on paper. At pressures between 18 and 22 gigapascals, cubic diamond has lower bulk enthalpy than lonsdaleite, meaning thermodynamics says it should form first. Yet it doesn't. Professor Pavel Sorokin and his team at the Skoltech Photonics Center discovered the explanation lies in the distinction between how large crystals and nanometer-scale nuclei behave. Creating a nucleus demands more than just rearranging atomic bonds—it requires building an interface with the surrounding graphite and deforming the parent material. These practical costs can overwhelm the structural advantage of cubic diamond at the smallest scales.
Using machine learning trained on quantum-mechanical calculations and models containing up to 700,000 atoms, the researchers demonstrated that lonsdaleite adapts far better to its graphite environment. The barrier to forming an optimal lonsdaleite nucleus is about half as high as for cubic diamond, and the critical number of atoms needed is two to three times smaller. In other words, nature takes the easier first step—even though it leads to a less stable intermediate product.
The study proposes that lonsdaleite nucleates first, then gradually transforms into cubic diamond as it grows and the boundary with graphite relaxes. This scenario isn't inevitable; if conditions prevent the restructuring, lonsdaleite can persist as a permanent feature of the material. This distinction matters enormously for practical applications, since controlling which form emerges affects the properties of the final product.
The broader lesson extends far beyond diamonds. This work demonstrates that the path to the most stable material isn't always obvious or direct. Understanding how interfacial strain influences nucleation gives researchers more precise control over synthesizing superhard materials and predicting their properties. The findings also carry implications for modeling extreme-pressure processes deep within planetary interiors, where similar phase transitions may occur under conditions we can barely simulate on Earth.