Researchers at the University of Cape Town warn that nature-based solutions for climate adaptation are failing informal settlements across Africa because they sidestep residents' lived experiences and bypass power imbalances.
Dr. Petra Holden and Professor Gina Ziervogel from the African Climate & Development Initiative published a comment in Nature Communications calling on municipal planners, policymakers, and international climate funders to shift from participatory consultation to genuine power-sharing partnerships.
"Many nature-based solutions projects framed as co-design initiatives begin with predetermined ideas and priorities that originate outside informal settlements, rather than from those who live within them," Holden said.
Drawing on the Tuwe Pamoja project across four African cities including Cape Town, the authors illustrate competing priorities in places like Khayelitsha informal settlement. Residents there live along vulnerable river and wetland edges, accepting flood risks to secure housing. External experts may disagree on solutions. An ecologist might want to restore a wetland to its natural state while a city engineer prefers concrete storm drains. Residents themselves split between those seeking flood protection and those wanting vegetable gardens or play spaces for children. City officials debate whether to build concrete or nature-based structures, decisions that could mean demolishing homes.
"Unless we confront underlying power imbalances and bring in local voices and priorities, technocratic perspectives will continue to shape climate adaptation at the direct expense of vulnerable communities," Ziervogel said.
The researchers outline three pathways. First, acknowledging competing claims over land and water to deliberate fairly. Second, establishing power-sensitive partnerships through long-term trust-building and shared decision-making backed by funding models that resource local leaders and community facilitators. Third, embracing "care-full pluralism" that recognizes multiple ways of knowing alongside scientific approaches and lived experiences.