Indonesia's research ecosystem lacks the foundational support needed to produce Nobel Prize-winning discoveries, according to an analysis by Pijar Religia, a specially appointed researcher at Osaka University.
The article traces how major breakthroughs take decades to mature. Peter Hegemann's investigation into how green algae swim toward light eventually led to the 2026 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for optogenetics, a technique using light to control nerve cells. Similarly, Katalin Karikó and Drew Weissman's 2023 Nobel Prize-winning work on mRNA modifications began more than two decades before delivering vaccines that saved lives during COVID-19.
Indonesia's R&D spending stood at US$2.8 billion in 2024, or 0.23% of gross domestic product, with the private sector contributing only 14.96%. By contrast, the private sector drove 51.37% of R&D spending in Malaysia and roughly 74% in Thailand. Higher education institutions shouldered 71.02% of Indonesia's R&D budget.
Indonesia's 2025 Research and Community Service Guidelines mandate that researchers publish at least one paper in a reputable international journal annually under the Regular Fundamental Research scheme. This short-term metric encourages safe, predictable research over ambitious, high-risk work.
Japan's KAKENHI program demonstrates an alternative approach. While it requires strict accountability reporting, the guidelines explicitly avoid treating publication targets as make-or-break criteria and encourage global dissemination without rigid quotas.
China increased R&D spending to 2.8% of GDP in 2025, with basic research investment rising 13.3% year-on-year. Singapore committed S$37 billion to its Research, Innovation and Enterprise 2030 plan, balancing market applications with fundamental science support.
Religia argues Indonesia needs flexible evaluation frameworks that allow exploratory ideas room to develop, reliable long-term funding, and real opportunities for international collaboration rather than pursuing a Nobel Prize as an end goal itself.