Scientists disagree about what science actually is more than members of the public do, according to research published in Royal Society Open Science. Marina Dubova, now an assistant professor of psychology at the University of California, Berkeley, led the study with Princeton University researcher Qiawen E. Liu.

The researchers surveyed 91 scientists and 99 members of the public. Participants assessed 18 descriptions of science drawn from historical perspectives, including comparisons to detective work, a pursuit of truth, and a mirror reflecting reality.

Both groups agreed that curiosity, exploration, and solving mysteries are central to science. Beyond that, scientists expressed strikingly different perspectives. Some viewed science primarily as discovering objective truths. Others emphasized imagination, personal judgment, and creative decisions in research. Scientists also disagreed on whether progress depends mainly on following established procedures or adapting as challenges arise.

Members of the public, by contrast, expressed more consistent views. They regarded science as a dependable way to discover objective truths, placing less importance on uncertainty and creativity.

"What was surprising to me was that there was quite a bit of disagreement between scientists, including scientists who are in the same subfield," Dubova says.

The public's understanding of science more closely resembled the views of physicists and biologists than those of psychologists and social scientists. One possible reason is that physics and biology receive greater attention in science education, though Dubova notes this explanation remains tentative and requires additional investigation.

The differences between scientists and public could help explain misunderstandings about scientific uncertainty. People expecting science to produce firm answers may struggle to understand why findings conflict or why conclusions must be updated with new evidence.

Dubova is also concerned that as artificial intelligence becomes involved in scientific discovery, automation could favor one particular approach to research, giving less attention to other valuable methods of discovery.