In 2025, 1.16 million people around the world were killed in road collisions—3,178 deaths per day. In the U.K. alone, 1,594 people died on the roads, with over 29,000 seriously injured. These numbers demand urgent action, but current policy approaches are fundamentally misdirected. Rather than continuing to focus criminal law on punishing individual 'bad' drivers, we must recognize that road violence is a systemic design failure requiring environmental regulation.
The current legal framework perpetuates what might be called 'motonormative punishment'—a system that targets the minority of drivers who cause injury through dangerous, careless, or impaired driving, while communicating to everyone else that driving is basically safe. Courts sentence convicted drivers to fines, community service, or prison, yet this approach neglects the central question: how do we actually reduce future driving risk? By focusing on individual culpability, criminal law obscures the systemic harms of car-centric mobility and normalizes deaths on a scale we would find utterly unacceptable in other contexts.
The vulnerability patterns underlying road deaths reveal the true injustice. Traffic collisions are the biggest global killer of children and young people aged 5 to 29. Those at greatest risk are the poor, children, the elderly, and especially pedestrians, cyclists, and motorcyclists. These are not random accidents—they are predictable consequences of how we design our streets and prioritize vehicles over people's safety.
Research published in the British Journal of Criminology this year argues compellingly for reframing road safety as environmental regulation rather than criminal punishment. As Professor Ian Loader states, these tragedies are 'the predictable and preventable result of choices we make about the number and nature of vehicles on our streets, how those streets are designed, and how we think about people's safety and freedom.' This reframing demands we stop treating car harms as isolated accidents and instead redesign the wider systems, environments, and rules that enable them.
While drivers who cause harm must continue to face responsibility, we cannot pretend that thousands of annual deaths and injuries are simply the unfortunate price of mobility or the fault of a few reckless individuals. If we are serious about road safety, criminal law and punishment must take a back seat to systemic environmental redesign. The question before policymakers is not how to punish more drivers, but how to build streets where harm is architecturally impossible.