Thierry Soussi, a cancer geneticist at Uppsala University in Sweden, identified more than 220 research papers describing impossible patterns of protein expression in genetically altered cell lines. The papers report proteins appearing in imaging experiments even though the cells lack the genes needed to produce them.
Cell lines are groups of cells derived from a single origin cell and cultured for laboratory experiments. Some cancer cell lines have been genetically modified with mutations and deletions to remove genes that control cell division, allowing researchers to study tumor progression and test treatments.
The MCF-7 cell line, which lacks the gene for caspase-3 protein involved in cell death, provides a key example. In 2009, researchers warned that some studies using MCF-7 have reported caspase-3 expression in western blots, an imaging technique identifying proteins by molecular weight.
Journals are retracting or correcting the affected work. Soussi notes that additional examples of the issue appear in already-retracted papers not included in his analysis. "This problem will not go away," Soussi says. "This is only the tip of a gigantic iceberg."