Researchers Claire Hart, Carmen Șurariu, and Kathy Carnelley studied how personality traits shape people's experiences on social media. Their work appears in two papers: one in Behaviour & Information Technology and another in the Journal of Research in Personality.
The team examined over 1,000 social media users across Brazil, Indonesia, and the United Kingdom. They measured three narcissistic traits: narcissistic admiration (wanting to stand out and gain admiration), narcissistic rivalry (maintaining superiority by devaluing others), and vulnerable narcissism (fragile self-esteem and sensitivity to rejection).
People higher in narcissistic admiration reported more favorable social media interactions, including greater attention, validation, and relationship opportunities. Those higher in narcissistic rivalry and vulnerable narcissism reported less favorable experiences, feeling less close to others and receiving less attention.
In a second study, the researchers followed 154 adults over 21 days, tracking what they posted and what responses they expected versus received. The pattern held: narcissistic admiration correlated with better perceived outcomes, while rivalry and vulnerable narcissism correlated with poorer relationship outcomes.
The researchers initially hypothesized that people with different narcissistic traits presented themselves differently online. However, they found this didn't explain the differences. Instead, expectations mattered. People higher in vulnerable narcissism expected to be more popular than they subsequently felt they were. When posts failed to achieve what people hoped, this gap was keenly felt by those with higher vulnerable narcissism, and vulnerable narcissism correlated with lower well-being overall.
The researchers note they measured people's perceptions of responses, not objective counts of likes or comments. The findings suggest that the same social media environment may be experienced differently depending on what users expect from it and their personality traits.